I Got A Citi Dividend American Express Card Without Asking For One (But It’s OK!)

I saw a post a few weeks ago on Consumerism Commentary where Flexo got a credit card that he didn’t ask for and really wasn’t all that happy about it.   When Citi sent a replacement credit card for his Dividend MasterCard, they also sent an American Express card.

I read the story with interest, because both my wife and I hold Dividend MasterCards and use them as our primary credit cards, turning down other cards in favor of the cash back that our Dividends card gives us. Most of Flexo’s readers that left comments were similarly put off by getting a card ‘forced’ without asking.

So, when my replacement card came in the mail last week, I looked inside, and also found two cards.  My MasterCard had the same account number, just with a new expiration date.  The American Express card was right there as well.

I sat down and read some of the questions on the FAQ sheet attached.  Here’s a brief rundown:

  • You can’t activate just one card without the other (hmmm…not good so far)
  • It only shows up as one account on your credit card (OK, that’s not so bad)
  • For the first twelve months, you get an extra 0.2% cash back when you use the AmEx card over the Master Card, so for purchases where you would get 1%, you get 1.2% and on their rotating special categories you could get up to 5.2%. (Not a huge improvement but a few extra bucks in my pocket is a few extra bucks in MY pocket, OK)
  • Everything shows up on one billing statement and transaction list.  No need to log in to two accounts or pay two bills or anything like that.

I wasn’t too bothered by all this and was sort of neutral by the whole thing, so I decided to activate the card.  I’ve had the card since 2004, have never paid a lick of interest, and have gotten cash back in the four figures, so I was OK with it.  During my call, though, I actually realized this could be a good thing for me.

The automated schpeel was going through the ‘benefits’ of the additional card, notably that you got the extra 0.2%, when they also mentioned “and you can use it at merchants everywhere like,, and Costco.”

Wait a minute, did she just say Costco?

Yep.  She did.

Costco only accepts cash, debit cards, or American Express payments.  We don’t do much in the way of cash for most of our spending.  We only want and have one credit card each (the Citi Dividends card), so we never went with an American Express.  This meant that our Costco purchases get made using our debit card.

This worked, but our days of getting any rewards for using our debit card are long gone.  But, with the new AmEx card add-on, I can swipe it at Costco and get cash back!  Now, our Costco spending isn’t astronomical so this isn’t going to make us rich, but it will definitely add some extra cash back in our pockets, and every little bit of that helps, right?

Now, I know there are other cards that give you better rewards at Costco.  I get that.  But, I try to keep a minimum number of credit cards for the sake of convenience and for keeping my credit score pristine.  Now, I can get some cash back and not have any additional payments to make or any additional credit lines showing on my credit report.

I’m more than good with that.

Have you heard of having one credit card with two different providers?  Are you in Flexo’s court where you think this is a bad idea or am I onto something by being OK with this?

8 thoughts on “I Got A Citi Dividend American Express Card Without Asking For One (But It’s OK!)”

  1. I had never heard about getting two credit cards like that until I read about it from Flexo and here. I wouldn't know what to begin to think since it just seems so baffling to me. Did your credit limit change?

  2. It definitely sounds like a good deal. I personally use 2-3 cards to maximize the rewards. I actually just hashed out how I use credit cards (to be published in Nov). I love getting cash back for things I am already going to buy and I wouldn't say no to an extra .2%. 🙂

  3. I'm confused about the Amex/ MasterCard mashup thing going on. That's weird.

    That said we shop at Costco a LOT so we use Amex for all our purchases. I've been very happy with Amex.

  4. I would actually be angry if that happened–if I could not activate my replacement card without activating the one they were shoving onto me. I like to keep things simple.

  5. @Amanda – Over on Flexo's site, some of the commenters indicated that you could opt out of the AmEx card by talking to someone but no, you can't do it via the automated activation system. On the plus side, I've found that nowadays when trying to activate a card, I always have to speak to someone anyways to say no to their credit protection service. This annoys me. With this activation they didn't make me talk to anyone, probably because they want as many people to activate as possible *lol*

  6. I shop at Costco so it could be a good thing. Does seem kind of weird though MC and Amx combining. Is this a hint of things to come?

  7. How is an Amex card associated with a Citi card? Wait, are all the banks really one bank? Did they get all combined in the whole bailout stimulus shenanigans?

    I recall seeing a Bank of America Amex card once also.

Comments are closed.